(First and foremost, read Claude Scilley's obituary piece on Doug Hargreaves. It was a mic drop; it's almost foolish enough to think there is a need for another piece.)

Well before terms such as team culture got buzz-phrased to death, Doug Hargreaves was nurturing it at Queen's every day, being the mindful keeper of that gold, blue and red flame that burns on fall Saturdays in Kingston and in the hearts of Gaels the world over.

Flowery, I know. It seems to be about the only way to lead off a personal post regarding the iconic Queen's football coach, who died at age 84 on Tuesday. It seems slightly more novel to talk about the lasting influence of Hargreaves and  his best Queen's teams. The people who truly knew him have the anecdotes and aphorisms, and Google can fill you in on his accomplishments.

There was nothing idealistic or intellectual about latching on to the Gaels during my adolescent/early teenage life phase, which is when people begin locking in their influences and tastes. I needed to identify with something positive and successful. In those years, 1988 through '92, Hargreaves' second Vanier Cup-winning season, the Gaels were winning a lot, competing in the Dunsmore Cup game every season.

(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

Before we get to the low-hanging fruit on the obvious joke tree, actual news pertaining to university football. The Regina Rams and Saskatchewan Huskies, according to confirmed reports, are slated to play their Oct. 1 game at new Mosaic Stadium. It will be a test event before the CFL's Roughriders move in for next season.

That fits in with a theme of transition in Riderville, since this is the first season with a new football ops staff and the last season at (I still call it) Taylor Field. Philosopher-king Chris Jones has been out with the old and in with the nucleus. It probably mans extra media responsibilities for Rob Bagg during road trips, since he 31-year-old wide receiver will be the only 'Rider the writers and TV reporters will be able to identify. Ba dum tish.
Minor beef: like a lot of teams, Saskatchewan no longer distinguishes between wideouts (WR) and slotbacks (SB) on the website roster. The franchise of Ray ElgaardJeff Fairholm and Joey Walters should feel great shame. So should you, if you do not know why.  


(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

Changing the team name to the Edmonton Exceptionalism would be a great and self-referential ironic way to address the #NotYourMascot issue.

Sure, everyone looks for a chance to throw shade at the current league champions, but Edmonton seems to think it is above a lot of the requirements of a sports team, like marketing or media access.


(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

Basically, B.C. is playing a 3-2-1-1 alignment with their national starters — the three interior O-linemen, two receivers, a D-tackle and Mike Edem of Calgary Dinos fame as the safety.

That is sub-optimal, as the kids say, and more than a bit of an indictment of how the Lions' depth has ebbed since the dizzying high of that Grey Cup victory way back in 2011. They started the season with a 20-18 home victory against Calgary by the margin of Chris Rainey housing a 72-yard punt return, but there is a reason they are not expected to contend for any big prizes.

One positive note for the Lions is that Charles Vaillancourt (Laval) has locked down the starting right guard job on merit. The left unsaid is that B.C. has already moved on from several of their '14 and '15 choices.


One point of a hobby blog is to present ideas that would seem cockamamie to people 'inside the bubble,' but which are actually salable and realistic. Hey, no one likes blue-sky thinking.

Credit where credit is due of course, so kudos to Canada West for realizing the perfect divisional alignment is not having one. The conference is going to the RPI-offs format with "a single conference, featuring a 20-game regular season schedule. Each team will play four geographical, or historical opponents every year, with games against six of the remaining 12 opponents every other year."

That is brilliant, on a couple counts. It basically means a coach and her/his players only have to prepare for 10 opponents during the conference season, which would ideally help facilitate better matchups (but hey, you never know, since basketball will happen). The athletic directors just made that part of the job easier, so it seems confusing that the coaches are so disgruntled about it.

It should help with promotion. Utilizing RPI here also makes sense, since the conference is adopting an unbalanced schedule.


(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

When a franchise has been out of the playoffs four seasons in a row, there are are systemic problems. Well, the Winnipeg Blue Bombers have at least addressed one by adding Craig Smith to their scouting department. Smith's tenure in Saskatchewan coincided with the Roughriders' time on top of the league, but he was swept aside when Chris Jones' staff took over in December.

So there is that. Winnipeg shares a stadium with a strong Canada West team, the Manitoba Bisons, who have 12 alumni in the league. Coach Michael O'Shea and GM Kyle Walters are each Guelph football alumni. One would have thought that would create a homing instinct to get an inside track on acquiring Canadian-trained players.

As far the season goes, Johnny Adams and Andrew Harris are already banged-up. The only big game Investors Group Field will likely host after the autumn solistice will come when the Winnipeg Jets host a Heritage Classic in mid-October. Winnipeg is going to get better, though.

And if The Simpsons dialogue that just popped into your head was Lisa saying, "What are you basing that on?" and Marge diverting attention with, "Who wants ginger snaps?", reward yourself for being so meta. Preferably with a healthy snack, not ginger snaps.

Receivers / backs — Having Winnipeg-raised Harris, he of the 1,527 receiving-rushing yards last season, creates a need for a Canadian backup. Pascal Lochard (Laval) fills the role of running back by trade who work into two-back sets and play special teams. Christophe Normand (Laval) is the lone active Bomber listed at fullback.

Out wide, perhaps I did not watch enough Winnipeg games last season, but it feels like Kris Bastien (Concordia), Julian Feoli-Gudino (Laval) and Rory Kohlert (Saskatchewan) are three types of the same wide receiver. All three are between 6-foot and 6-3, 206 and 213 pounds, and in the second half of their twenties.

Addison Richards (Regina) is bigger (6-4, 221) and has greater upside than the three older national wideouts. Richards is on the injured list.

Venerable Winnipeg play-by-player Bob (Knuckles) Irving will not have any issue distinguishing Nos. 81, 83 and 87. Mere mortals might struggle with that, and distinguishing between Weston Dressler and Ryan Smith when both waggle out as slotbacks.

Offensive line — Any dedicated fan of O-line play gets an little endorphin high when Patrick Neufeld (Saskatchewan) gets singled out for doing good work, since he is among the few, the proud starting Canadian tackles in the league. Neufeld and guard Sukh Chungh (Calgary) form an all-Canadian right side.

One hates to keep playing the 'woebegone Winnipeg' card, but 11-year veteran centre Jeff Keeping (Western) is out eight weeks with a knee injury after being a big free-agent add. Third-year Matthias Goossen (Simon Fraser, NCAA D-2) has drawn in at centre after making 10 starts in '15.

Defensive front sevenKeith Shologan in the interior and Jamaal Westerman with his 17-sack season at rush end addresses a lot of national-starter needs. It goes without saying that it is better to draft and develop that than pay for past performance come free-agency time in Februrary, but hey, I would have also preferred to have not been born a redhead.

Jake Thomas (Acadia) is the next national up at D-tackle. Jesse Briggs (McGill) and Shayne Gauthier (Laval) are the depth 'backers. That is apparently not the same as being a DB.

Defensive secondary Teague Sherman (Manitoba) has a prized skill-set that allows him to cover several spots in the back eight. Taylor Loffler (UBC) cracked the roster as a big-bodied safety (6-4, 220) who can contribute on special teams. Stay observation: Loffler is a 24-year-old rookie, but fellow CIS grad Brendan Morgan (Queen's) is in his second season and is still only 22. Derek Jones (Simon Fraser, CIS/NCAA D-2), a second-generation CFL D-back, likely is the odd one out if Winnipeg is able to have an all-internationals secondary.

Specialists — Long snapper Chad Rempel (Saskatchewan) is hiking the ball to Justin Medlock (well, actually his holder) and punter Sergio Castillo. Two international spots used on foot-to-ballers? That just seems odd.
(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

Like any good fan, I oscillate 180 degrees on the  Canadian quarterback debate.

Of course, this is in the Stampeders post since Andrew Buckley earned the No. 3 quarterback job fully on his merits, beating out Bryant Moniz. The 22-year-old Calgary Dinos grad took on the 27-year-old from a FBS passing factory, Hawai'i, and proved he had the best combination of skills and unscratched potential. It is even more encouraging to see that since this is happening with the strongest organization in the CFL, which hasn't been wrong about quarterbacks too often over the past decade.

The realist argument is that there should be an open market to play the most important position in the game. That means any Canadian passer with CFL ambitions has to accept that it is one vs. 100 in comparison to competing against Americans who have likely played D-1 or D-2, run a spread offence since junior high and played in 7-in-7 leagues. Professional teams have only finite patience with incoming athletes and Americans in the Nopuck team sports develop more quickly than Canadians, probably due to more intense youth leagues and the parental prerogative for early one-sport specialization.


(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

Boris Bede, apart from international tournaments, has played all of his football in Quebec with Laval and the Als. Yet by rule, the Alouettes kicker and punter counts as an international. Figure that out.

Pardon the soap-boxing, but yes, there should be some reworking of the definition of a national player to include those who received their amateur football training in Canada. Who knows, it might help the profile of CIS if players in Europe know there is a country and a league they could adapt to better than the US of A.

Of course, accommodating an anomaly such as Bede is the least of Montreal's issues, which appear to be many. Revolving door at quarterback! Callow offensive line tasked with keeping the 37-year-old QB1 upright for 18 games! A good general manager whose hiring searches for a coach begin, and end, by looking in the mirror! Game presentation that puts off female fans! Those are all agenda items for other blogs.

As far as the CIS guys are concerned, the big take-home is the Alouettes have Philippe Gagnon starting at guard fresh out of Laval. Thank you for not making parallels between that personnel move and how Ottawa had 2015 No. 1 overall pick Alex Mateas work in as a backup after being drafted out from the D-1 Connecticut Huskies.

Fun fact: the Alouettes' roster includes players from five RSEQ schools. The one not represented also plays home games at Molson Stadium.


(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

To dissemble in Costanza-esque fashion, the Tiger-Cats are right in the meaty part of the curve with how they use their Canadian talent — not showing off, not falling behind.

The five Canadians on the offence are the centre, both guards, an inside receiver and a wideout, and all five played in CIS. The two Canadians on the D both played Division 1. Defensive tackle Ted Laurent played for Mississippi (where Ticats HC Kent Austin once coached) and safety Courtney Stephen played at Northern Illinois after transferring from Laurier.

To be fair, Stephen is the safety spot normally occupied by erstwhile all-star Craig Butler (Western), who has a knee injury that will likely need extensive rest in order to heal. Otherwise Hamilton would have a surplus of nationals who are established starters.

(Over the next few days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters. It should be 10, five on each side of the ball, but one battle at a time ... one battle at a time.)

The Argonauts' directors of scouting on each side of the border, Vince Magri and Spencer Zimmerman, are each former OUA O-linemen. Thus it is not surprising that their roster has a strong southern Ontario flavour with 14 OUA alumni — three  apiece from McMaster, Guelph, U of T and York, and two from Western. Unofficially, Toronto has 22 nationals who got some of their training in CIS.

The brightest young nationals might be the two former Manitoba Bisons, though, SB Anthony Coombs and LB Thomas Miles.

Coombs is listed as a running back but in use and deed, he's a 'slash back,' to borrow a Chip Kelly-ism. Broadly, that is a receiver with a running back build and skill set, and Coombs contributed 486 of his 525 receiving-rushing yards through the passing phase. Miles was also a nice second-half revelation last season, starting seven games from Sept. 26 onward.

Whether the Argonauts' plethora of CIS alumni is pertinent to the 'turf war' between the football fans and Toronto FC fans is debatable. That said, it is a taxpayer-funded stadium and the football team really is focused on developing Canadian and Ontario players. That should count for something, no?

(Over the next nine days, this blog will do its best to give a rundown on how CIS alumni figure into the grand scheme for each CFL team. Friendly reminder: the ratio in the CFL requires each team to have seven 'nationals' among the 24 defensive and offensive starters.)

With the right side of the Ottawa Redblacks offensive line in flux, Jake Harty is showing that he can foster some flexibility with the ratio.

The Redblacks, needless to say, did not take Harty from the Calgary Dinos with the No. 10 overall choice in 2015 just to have him tear downfield like a banshee on punt and kickoff coverage. The 25-year-old is showing more polish as a wide-side wide receiver while working with the Henry Burris-helmed first-string offence. Burris and Harty renewed their Calgary connection early in Monday's excruciation game against the Winnipeg Blue Bombers, with the second-year wideout getting two catches for 36 yards from his three targets. Harty made a nice cut on a post route for a 22-yard catch on Ottawa's opening series. In the second quarter, Harty laid out for a 14-yard catch to help Ottawa pick up on second-and-8. In his time, he ran tight, precise routes on almost every down, which is a good indicator for someone at the receiver spot that typically sees the fewest targets.

"For me, the mental game, coming back and understanding the playbook, is huge," Harty said after the 18-14 Redblacks win. "Understanding the mental game builds your confidence. You're able to go out there and play and not think. You know what to expect.

"This off-season, I've been working on my routes, everything. It is the little things when you get to the next level."


Two out of three is not bad, as a shooting percentage or regarding changes to Ontario University Athletics' RPI-offs.

 The end of last season pointed up three issues with the format. The Ryerson Rams ended up with the No. 1 seed for the Wilson Cup men's playoffs since a loss to the Guelph Gryphons did not factor into the RPI. The Gryphons, at 9-10, did not make the playoffs since they were fourth in the OUA Central whilst Laurier (9-11), Laurentian (6-13) and Toronto (5-14) got inside the velvet rope. That was not right.

To its credit, OUA is rectifying that for 2016-17, as CANhoops related:

  • All games count in crunching the RPI;
  • The top 12 teams in RPI, regardless of division, make the playoffs. 
That is at it should be. Critics of RPI, of course, hold that the reliance on strength of schedule means it rewards teams more for losses to strong opponents than it does for winning.

It's a good idea to have it in OUA when the West division plays 20 games and everyone else plays 19. However, it can favour the teams that are in a division with one or two of the usual suspects (Carleton, Ottawa and the Rams). It can also affect an team from the West that has one-fifth of its schedule against expansion Algoma and rebuilding Waterloo.

A third tweak would have been to half-weight divisional games. Maybe next year, eh. Two changes is a good start.

The men's and women's schedules are online. Of note, Final 8 host Dalhousie will be in the GTA on the first weekend of October for some non-conf. action.
BACK IN THE 613 — Hopefully, CIS will know what it is selling when new CEO Graham Brown begins pounding the pavement to drum up new sponsorship.

Based on Brown's track record at Rugby Canada, there should be every confidence that the national organization will be be a finer fiduciary health eventually, if not immediately. One hope, for his and everyone's sake, it will not get too frustrating  trying to get major corporations to invest in a league that has a marginal national TV presence and whose largest regional association, Ontario University Athletics, has no TV contract.

When one brings that up, almost always the immediate retort is that things are tough all over for amateur sport in Canada, which is bearing the brunt of a shrinking salaried-and-benefited media. True, but that does not preclude having a honest conversation about how they can convince national advertisers to invest.

The prevailing takeaway from that Globe that appeared on the first day of the CIS AGM was that the conversation has not happened. The between-the-lines tip-offs was that Michael Mahon, and perhaps this stemmed from how the reporter posed his question, mentioned the NCAA.

Right away, that is a deal-breaker for an org. that is already dealing with the public perception is is a some Canadian K-Tel knockoff of the NCAA. One can certainly learn something from U.S. college sports about marketing hype. What goes on down south cannot be replicated in Canada, for two little-known reasons.



  1. The CRTC. This is straight outta the piece that Wayne  Kondro wrote for the CIS website in April: " ... once was the case that networks received broadcast licenses from the Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission that included specific conditions that they fill at least 27% of their airspace with university and amateur sports."

    That was why TSN produced a game of the week in the 1980s and '90s. That was why there might not be much hope for "a nationally televised game-of-the-week idea [that] is also in the planning stage" getting off of the ground.
  2. Watching Division 1 college-sponsored semi-pro football counts as a charitable activity. Have you ever heard any general-interest grouser who has a written an ain't-that-a-shame CIS vs. NCAA comparison, or one of those best-kept secret pieces, bring this up?

    I was unaware of this until reading Gilbert M. Gaul's Billion-Dollar Ball: A Journey Through The Big-Money Culture Of College Football this winter. In the U.S., since football is part of a university's "educational mission," an athletic department might levy a "seat donation" fee on top season tickets that can range into five figures annually for premium seats. But that seat donation, thanks to the U.S. Congress digging their nails into the IRS' arm  in the late 1980s, is 80 per cent tax deductible. For instance, Gaul found that in 2012 the Georgia Bulldogs raked in $22 million US in seat donations on top of what they already generated in ticket sales.

    The schools defend the tax deduction by saying it pays for non-revenue or low-revenue sports.  That is the fourth wall in the explosion of college-sponsored football in the States in the last quarter-century, with spin-offs for sports ESPN has gone heavy on such as women's basketball and fastpitch.
Those are two pretty immovable objects to contend with. It should not take someone who (inside joke alert) called Ottawa Gee-Gees games while Gary Etcheverry was coaching in 2012 to tell you that using a playbook from the last century will get you stuck in third-and-14 very quickly.

In terms of being prescriptive, CIS ought to realize outside-in top-down national marketing strategies are passé. The way it works now is inside-out. Get people to vote with their feet and their social media accounts to be part of that groundswell.

Do rivalry games make aesthetically appealing TV? Of course they do, but what demographic does it reach, especially in a country as vast as Canada? In an age of cord-cutters and cord-nevers, it's hard to imagine how enough football/basketball fans in Toronto or Windsor or Vancouver will be impelled to put on Carleton-Ottawa, or Laval-Montreal football, and care about the outcome. Yet they care when it is a Big Ten or SEC game.

Each is great in its way. The point is that we in Canada have to accept that the other has a lot more propping it up that our Nopuck sports might never have, since hockey is a pig on resources.

Hence the notion of working inside-out. There is a great example of that in Ottawa that does not come from either CIS school, although each does a great job. It's more how OSEG has collaborated with the soccer community to make the Ottawa Fury FC a prism through which to view the whole sport. When the Fury launched, they put ads across the city that implored people to, "Cheer Locally." The messaging was, as, as a commentator would put it, brilliant.

Hey, you in the Messi jersey, here is a team in your orbit that can open up a whole new way to appreciate our great sport.

When one goes to a Fury game, they get a Canadian scale model of the footy experience. They have supporter sections with their banners and chants. There's a communal experience when people are moving toward the stadium. Now, they have a benefit that Getting Soccer connotes worldliness, the scourge of ultras notwithstanding. Soccer is also wondrous into how it can all be interconnected and offer something different than a schedule of regular-season games and potential playoff dates.

In the past three weeks, Ottawa was blessed enough to give people four different types of competition:

  • The Fury's first-round Cup game against a league team;
  • A Fury league game on a Friday night;
  • Fury a semifinal Cup game against the Vancouver Whitecaps, where they got their first win against a MLS side in front of more than 9,000 people;
  • Building off hosting 2015 Women's World Cup games, they drew more than 23,000 to a Canada-Brazil game on Tuesday; it did not hurt that Canada won 1-0 after scoring in the 90th minute.
That is how a team and a sport becomes a talker. One can also feel like part of the sport's whole ecosystem, all the way up to Messi.

That apples-and-pomegranates part of that, of course, is that one cannot directly compare between minor league soccer put on by an entertainment firm and games put on by a school's Department of Athletics and Recreation.

Do you get anything like that in CIS in terms of the vibe? The scale-model Canadian take on what the rooting experience is all about?

Abso-frigging-lutely. The numbers are not there, of course. But go to a gym for basketball or volleyball when two skilled teams are playing, and there are people who are healthily emotionally invested in it. You see that in football, too. Often times, though it can feel like the game is being played in a lab and is cut off from the rest of the sport's world. It's not appealing to people who expect the Big Sport experience to sit on fold-down bleachers. It also hurts that the only time CIS gets media exposure is on Super Championship Weekend, and most students cannot afford to go thousands of kilometres when their team might only play one championship side game.

That is CIS' reality, and it needs to play up how it stays small and yet punches above their weight. Brown has something special, and honestly it is a little infuriating to see old media present the challenge as one of relevancy.

It is relevant, because of what it is, and what it is not. It wouldn't be Canadian if it was not something else.

That is what Brown needs to take to advertisers. That is what almost each school needs to take to their community to get more people out at their games, if not all games.

I'll end with some brainstorming about how to attempt this, since chances are no one has hung in this long:

  • Get the point across that CIS reaches into every cranny of Canadian sport. Why isn't there some marketing that emphasizes that Mike Babcock, one of the most powerful people in the hockey industry, honed his coaching chops when he guided the Lethbridge Pronghorns to the University Cup in 1994? Every Leafs fan should know that.

    With this being an Olympic year, how does one get across to the public how many athletes do choose to develop in Canada, even without the full scholarships?

    No disrespect, but that takes more than sending out a press release that points out 800-metre runner Melissa Bishop or freestyle swimmer Ryan Cochrane, or an up-and-coming swimmer such as U of T's Kylie Massé, is CIS alumni. Chances are, that press release sent out some day  in July is not getting read. It also does not explain why those athletes opted for Canada and Canadian coaching instead of going south.
  • Play up your 'Radically Canadian' basketball. What got the CFL off the schneid in the mid-1990s after the U.S. expansion foundered was saying, hey, we got the better game than the guys down south, albeit without as good athletes or as much money.

    That is exactly what is going on in men's and women's hoops. It is the only high-level league in North America that plays the superior (no argument will be brooked on this) FIBA game, which is quicker, more player-first and more strenuous. (That said, this season's Shamateur Sports Hunger Games Hoops Invitational was the most watchable in a decade, which owes to the NCAA addressing its pace-of-play problems.)

    The way the Golden State Warriors are playing now is pretty much the same model that Smart has inculcated at Carleton for almost 20 years. In women's hoops, hile casual fans are vaguely aware that SWNT point guard Kia Nurse is part of the Connecticut Huskies juggernaut, how many know that her backup, Miah-Marie Langlois, developed playing for Chantal Vallée with another dynasty with the Windsor Lancers?
  • Show the value of the transformational relationships that are possible in CIS. Everywhere in the world, people under age 45 or so are tired of being treated like a number. They want something authentic.

    How does that apply to CIS in its age-old battle to not be compared to NCAA? It would be fun to know what the percentage is of CIS athletes who play 4-5 seasons for one head coach compared to their NCAA D1 counterparts. It would be much, much higher in CIS, since coaches stay and, at least ideally, do more teaching than just try to keep building their program and tossing aside those who don't fit.

    Create the same, "I'm giving my money to something positive," that fair-trade coffee shops use to get people to pay more instead of going to a chain. That segues into the next bullet point.
  • What does your product have that the more accessible, more popular alternative lacks? Lots. For starters, CIS has a better, more diverse roster of sports. The NCAA's dirty little secret is that for all the pomp and circumstance of football and men's basketball, and the spin-off niches built up, a Division I school on average sponsors fewer sports than the larger CIS members.

    I can already hear the calls that it would be more manageable to start cutting sports. That overlooks CIS' mandate is to graduate student-athletes, and what message does it send to try to make up for one's shortcomings on the backs of water polo, especially in an increasingly sedentary, screen-struck society? Boo to that.

    Being willing to have a big all-sports tent is part of what makes CIS great. This needs to broken off into another bullet point, actually.
     
  • Show advertisers and consumers what you have that the Other Guys do not. Beyond the big three (football, hockey, hoops), CIS' strength is that it is diverse.

    For instance, it was way ahead of the game on accepting women's wrestling. It has a growing women's rugby culture. Each of those sports are producing Olympians. It is sad that is reduced to obscurity, but that's Canada and what passes as for media for you.

    Perhaps that also means tweaking the Other Guys. It's great fun to point out Canada beat America to having a true football playoff by 47 years!
  • Take the game to the masses a little more. Calgary and Ben Matchett deserve so much credit for engaging people on their campus by adopting the rivalry game concept. Not only have they drawn 13,000 to an annual Mount Royal Cougars-Dinos matchup at the iconic Saddledome, but they also have used the concept to get more people out at the Dinos football opener.

    A few years ago, RMC and Queen's did the same with their annual Carr-Harris Cup men's hockey game. Throwing it together in just a couple weeks, they got 5,100 people out to the K-Rock Centre on a school night. That exceeded the typical turnout for the arena's main tenant. That shows there is interest, even if it's not every-game or most-games interest.

    Why isn't everyone with a decent basketball or hockey team and a rival in close proximity doing that right in the first few weeks in January, when there's a little giddiness on campus because classes have resumed but midterms and assignments are a few weeks off?
  • Get in front of televiewers on a more year-round basis. Scotch the game of the week idea. What would be a lot more brassy and nervy would be to decide Final 8 at-large berths by getting four teams together at points in the season to play for it.

    Curling has the 'berth spiel' concept at the provincial level. Why would that not work in sports with longer seasons? Get the best teams together right when everyone comes back in January — a time when many teams play a tournament — and have a little winner-take-all tournament. That would be a much more fun way for OUA and Canada West to decide their second berth into nationals. The 'semifinal winners go to nationals, bronze-medal game winner crosses their fingers and the gold-medal game is  for seeding' tradition is way too convoluted.

    It gives the haters more ammo. Never mind that a conference tournament in Division 1 basketball is often perfunctory for a team that will be a No. 1 or 2 seed.
  • Finally, football. It was tempting, whilst citing Billion-Dollar Ball, that the difference between college-sponsored football down south and Canadian university football is Big Money vs. No Money.

    That would be about the biggest crock of all time. There is a lot of money in CIS. However, how does it grow the game when UBC, Guelph, Carleton, Laval, Montreal, Queen's and Western have boosters pouring money into their programs by a factor of 4:1 or 5:1? Last anyone checked, you sort of need competition to have a league. You cannot have everyone else being the Minnesota Twins to several regional versions of the Yankees during the Peak Steinbrenner late 1990s.

    What is holding back football, is that a lot of the public cannot take it seriously since the coaches and boosters take it too seriously. Seeing Michael O'Connor lead UBC on a Vanier Cup run that went through Calgary, the Maritimes and Quebec was awesome on one level. On another, it sucked to know this was an end result of how much money David Sidoo and UBC's 13th man foundation are funneling into the Thunderbirds.

    That's great on its own, but apart from L. David Dubé with his Northern 8 concept, who among the moneymen is talking about building something sustainable for a 30-team sport?

    Not to keep picking on UBC, but how will that 2015 run look in hindsight if they just roll through the next few seasons?

    It might be impossible to fix that, but end of the day, the CIS and the university presidents have the hammer. They have been known to say no to a good offer. It would not be easy, but they need to get through to people that all that well-intentioned investment needs to be spread to all of the football teams.

    They are coming to a point where they might need a national co-operative to support football. That will be a tough sell, but you would think multi-millionaires and billionaires who love football that much would be comfortable with something where their beloved alma mater wouldn't have automatic W's against underfunded Waterloo or Windsor every year.

    And oh yeah, fix the Vanier Cup playoff structure.
That is not to say all this doable. It's just a few ideas that might position the CIS better for the next decade than chasing what they have lose over the past two decades.
Previous PostOlder Posts Home